The next Supreme Court pick could shape Indian law for decades

The highest court in the land holds legal power over tribal nations, but it lacks knowledge of tribal law.


Now that Justice Anthony Kennedy has announced his retirement from the U.S. Supreme Court, Indian Country is again asking what a new justice could mean for tribal interests. President Donald Trump’s pick for Kennedy’s replacement, Circuit Judge Brett Kavanaugh, has little experience with Indian law — something that’s in keeping with the court’s history. 

Federal Indian law is often unfamiliar territory to Supreme Court justices, even though the court makes significant decisions affecting tribal sovereignty, criminal jurisdiction, and land and water rights. That lack of understanding is reflected in the court’s decision-making: Over the last three decades, the court has ruled against tribal members and nations 72 percent of the time. Now, with the recent addition of Justice Neil Gorsuch, who is fluent in Indian law, and the departure of Kennedy, who actively voted against tribal interests, it remains to be seen how a new combination of justices will affect Indian Country.

“Things have improved in the last 30 years, but the percentage of win-loss is still pretty bad,” said Alex Tallchief Skibine, professor of law at the S.J. Quinney College of Law at the University of Utah.

Chief Arvol Looking Horse, of the Sioux Tribe, delivers a prayer during the rally in front of the United States Supreme Court following oral arguments in the Dollar General Corporation v. Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians case in 2015.
Bill Clark/AP Images

Starting in the 1820s, the Supreme Court laid the groundwork for the legal relationship between tribal, federal and state governments, acknowledging that tribal nations hold legal and political rights and are on par with the federal government. In the following decades, the court often deferred to Congress, which shifted its policy from subjugation to assimilation, and then to termination of federally recognized tribes in the 1950s. Few tribal nations could afford to hire lawyers.

“That meant they couldn’t defend themselves,” said Charles Wilkinson, Moses Lasky professor of law emeritus at the University of Colorado. “They had no money, and they couldn’t bring cases to assert their rights.”

Eventually, federal policy, spurred by congressional action, shifted towards encouraging self-determination. The modern era of Indian law began in the late 1960s with a series of decisions that expanded the purview of tribal law.

Those favorable decisions came about in part because Indigenous people finally received fair legal representation in court, a change that reflected the broader social and political movements for equality in America during that time. With more access to free legal services, along with newly acquired wealth from Indian gaming, tribal governments were able to challenge corporations and the state when treaty rights were threatened. 

“The tribe was optimistic in winning a lot of those battles because they had a lot of positive decisions up until the 1980s,” Skibine said. “And then the court kind of caught on to them.” 

After that, a number of decisions during Chief Justice William Rehnquist’s time gave states unprecedented jurisdiction over tribes. Duro v. Reina declared that tribes have no jurisdiction over nonmembers, for example. Tribes lost roughly 75 percent of the cases brought before the court.

That figure has not improved drastically over time. The justices are primarily from the coasts, almost entirely with East Coast educations and with little experience with Indian Country. Justice Stephen Breyer has made efforts to visit and understand tribal courts, and Justices Sonia Sotomayor and Neil Gorsuch have a thorough understanding of Indian law — in Sotomayor’s case, because she made a concerted effort to learn. “Because it was an area that I had no prior exposure to, I had to start from the beginning,” Sotomayor Gorsuch, meanwhile, had experience on the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals, which includes five Western states and 76 tribal nations. 

That leaves six justices with little to no experience in Indian law who are wary of recognizing tribal jurisdiction, specifically when it involves power over non-Natives. Dollar General Corp. v. Mississippi Band of Choctaw Indians came to the court in 2015. The case resulted in a 4-4 draw (due to the death of Justice Antonin Scalia) about whether or not the Choctaw could prosecute a non-Native man for allegedly sexually harassing a tribal citizen on tribal land. 

The court’s last term offered little indication of how the current court will treat tribal issues, despite a high number of Indian law cases. The biggest case, brought by 21 Pacific Northwest tribes against the state of Washington, raised the question of how far treaty rights protect the tribes’ right to salmon. The court was tied, thus affirming the state’s obligation to help protect the environmental conditions salmon need to survive — a massive win for tribes.

When Kavanaugh’s confirmation battle begins in Congress, questions about his experience with Indian law will likely not take center stage, given other concerns over his judicial record. But with the power to affect all 573 federally recognized tribes in the nation, the next justice has the potential to shape Indian law for decades to come.

Anna V. Smith is an assistant editor for NewTowncarShare News.

NewTowncarShare News Classifieds
  • in Southwest Colorado. $60K plus costs.
  • with six+ years of experience, broad knowledge of home and facilities maintenance. 207-805-4157,
  • Seeking full-time experienced farmer on 52-acre organic farm Union, OR. [email protected]
  • Western Resource Advocates (WRA) is seeking a Government Affairs Manager that is passionate about Western communities and the protection of the natural environment to support...
  • Metal roofing & siding, thru-fastened & seam profiles. Stronger, more attractive and longer lasting than any other panel on the market. 970-275-4070.
  • The Central Colorado Conservancy, a nationally accredited and state certified land trust, is seeking an innovative and dynamic Executive Director to guide the Conservancy into...
  • National conservation organization seeks a regular, full-time, Lake Tahoe West Senior Project Lead. Position is responsible for working with the National Forest Foundation (NFF) to...
  • Forever Our Rivers Foundation seeks a driven and creative individual to lead this national movement for river health. Deadline 6/14/19.
  • We are looking for an experienced campaigner to lead our work challenging the oil and fracked gas industry, specifically focused on fighting fossil fuel expansion...
  • 7/12-7/14/19 in Taos, NM. With over 21 workshops and keynote speaker, poet Arthur Sze.
  • Badlands Conservation Alliance is seeking an Executive Director. For job description visit
  • Everland Mountain Retreat includes 318 mountaintop acres with a 3,200 square foot lodge and two smaller homes. Endless vistas of the Appalachian mountains, open skies,...
  • Spectacular views of snowcapped Sierras. 15 miles from Kings Canyon/Sequoia Parks. 47 acres with 2 homes/75' pool/gym/patios/gardens. 1670 sq.ft. main home has 3 bdrm/1 bath....
  • Beautiful off-the-grid passive solar near the CDT. 9.4 acres, north of Silver City. Sam, 575.388.1921
  • at RCAC. See the full description at Apply at [email protected]
  • Newly refurbished and tuned. Older model, great condition. Gasoline engine. Chains on tires. Heavy duty for mountain snow. Call cellphone and leave message or email.
  • Camping, hiking, backpacking, R2R2R, Tarahumara Easter, Mushroom Festival,
  • Clean off, cool off & drink. Multiple spray patterns. Better than you imagine. Try it.
  • Actively introduce students to Experiential Education, Outdoor Recreation, and Sustainability while engaging and challenging them to learn and participate in these diverse opportunities. Room, board,...
  • 1400 sf of habitable space in a custom-designed eco-home created and completed by a published L.A. architect in 1997-99. Nestled within its own 80-acre mountain...